EC over-rules its officers, gives second clean chit to Narendra Modi

Lok Sabha Elections 2019: Polling schedule, results date, constituency-wise results, how to check live counting

Their opinion, The Indian Express has learnt, was debated vigorously in the Commission meeting Tuesday and was, eventually, over-ruled on the technicality that Modi did not seek votes for either his party or himself while invoking the Balakot air strikes.

According to an EC official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, the comments of the DEO and the CEO were not considered since their opinion was based on “just five lines of the speech”.

“The decision was made after taking the whole speech into consideration,” the official added.

“The matter has been examined in the context of extant ECI’s advisory dated 04.12.2013, which was reiterated on 09.03.2019 and a sequel issued on 19.03.2019, provisions of the Model Code of Conduct and after examination of complete transcript of speech of eleven pages as per the certified copy sent by the Returning Officer, 40-Osmanabad Parliamentary Constituency on 13.04.2019, Commission is of considered view that in this matter no such violation of the extant advisories/provisions is attracted,” states EC’s reply sent to Congress leader Randeep Singh Surjewala Tuesday.

READ | Modi’s majority-minority speech: EC says does not violate poll code

On March 19, the poll panel had written to all parties asking them to advise their leaders and candidates to “desist” from “indulging in any political propaganda involving activities of the Defence forces”.

Earlier on March 9, the Commission had issued a similar advisory to political parties asking them not to use photographs of defence personnel or photographs of functions involving defence personnel in advertisements or their election propaganda.

With Wednesday’s decision, the EC has cleared two of the five Congress complaints against the Prime Minister. On Tuesday, the Commission had found no violation of the MCC and electoral laws in Modi’s April 1 speech at Wardha where, referring to Congress President Rahul Gandhi’s decision to also contest from Wayanad, he had said that the party was “running away from majority-dominated areas” to “take refuge in areas where the majority is in minority”.

In his speech at Latur on April 9, which got the Commission’s all-clear Wednesday, Modi had said: “Mein zara kehna chhahta hoon mere first-time voteron ko. Kya aapka pehla vote Pakistan ke Balakot mein air strike karnewale veer jawanon ke naam samarpit ho sakta hai kya? Mein mere first-time voter se kehna chhahta hoon ki aapka pehla vote Pulwama mein jo veer shahid hue hain un veer shahidon ke naam aapka vote samarpit ho sakta hai kya?” (“I want to tell my first-time voters: Can your first vote be dedicated to the brave soldiers who carried out the air strike in Balakot in Pakistan? I want to tell my first-time voters: Can your first vote be dedicated to the braves martyred in Pulwama?”).

On April 12, the Congress had approached the Commission against the above comment calling it a “blatant and brazen act” and a “direct violation of EC’s instructions dated March 9 and March 19.

ALSO READ | Crystal clear that MCC has become ‘Modi Code of Conduct’: Congress on EC clean chit to PM Modi

The other Congress complaints against the PM relate to his remarks elsewhere: On April 6, in Nanded, Maharashtra, he again referred to the Wayanad seat as one where the “country’s majority is in minority”.

And on April 21, while speaking in Patan in Gujarat, Modi, referring to himself in third person, said he had 12 missiles ready and that had Pakistan not announced the return of Wing Commander Abhinandan then it would have had to face “qatal ki raat”. On the same day, addressing a rally in Barmer in Rajasthan, he warned Pakistan, saying India’s nuclear arsenal is not meant for Diwali. “Every other day they used to say ‘we have nuclear button, we have nuclear button’. What do we have then? Have we kept it for Diwali?” he said.

The Supreme Court on Thursday will hear Congress MP Sushmita Dev’s petition demanding urgent action on EC’s behalf on alleged MCC violations by Modi and BJP President Amit Shah.