• News
  • Farmers, technology and freedom of choice: A tale of two satyagrahas
This story is from June 30, 2019

Farmers, technology and freedom of choice: A tale of two satyagrahas

Farmers, technology and freedom of choice: A tale of two satyagrahas
I had a strange dream last night. I dreamt that the government had passed a law that made using laptops illegal. I would have to write this column by hand. I would also have to leave my home in Mumbai to deliver it in person to my editor in Delhi. I woke up trembling and angry — and realised how Indian farmers feel every single day of their lives.
My column today is a tale of two satyagrahas.
Both involve farmers, technology and the freedom of choice. One of them began this month — but first, let us go back to the turn of the millennium.
As the 1990s came to an end, cotton farmers across India were in distress. Pests known as bollworms were ravaging crops across the country. Farmers had to use increasing amounts of pesticide to keep them at bay. The costs of the pesticide and the amount of labour involved made it unviable — and often, the crops would fail anyway.
Then, technology came to the rescue. The farmers heard of Bt cotton, a genetically modified type of cotton that kept these pests away, and was being used around the world. But they were illegal in India, even though no bad effects had ever been recorded. Well, who cares about ‘illegal’ when it is a matter of life and death?
Farmers in Gujarat got hold of Bt cotton seeds from the black market and planted them. You’ll never guess what happened next. As 2002 began, all cotton crops in Gujarat failed — except the 10,000 hectares that had Bt cotton. The government did not care about the failed crops. They cared about the ‘illegal’ ones. They ordered all the Bt cotton crops to be destroyed.
It was time for a satyagraha — and not just in Gujarat. The late Sharad Joshi, leader of the Shetkari Sanghatana in Maharashtra, took around 10,000 farmers to Gujarat to stand with their fellows there. They sat in the fields of Bt cotton and basically said, ‘Over our dead bodies.’ Joshi’s point was simple: all other citizens of India have access to the latest technology from all over. They are all empowered with choice. Why should farmers be held back?

The satyagraha was successful. The ban was lifted.
There are three things I would like to point out here. One, the lifting of the ban transformed cotton farming in India. Over 90% of Indian farmers now use Bt cotton. India has become the world’s largest producer of cotton, moving ahead of China. According to agriculture expert Ashok Gulati, India has gained $67 billion in the years since from higher exports and import savings because of Bt cotton. Most importantly, cotton farmers’ incomes have doubled.
Two, GM crops have become standard across the world. Around 190 million hectares have been planted worldwide, and GM foods are accepted in 67 countries. The humanitarian benefits have been massive: Golden rice, a variety of rice packed with minerals and vitamins, has prevented blindness in countless newborns since it was introduced in the Philippines.
Three, despite the fear-mongering of some NGOs, whose existence depends on alarmism, the science behind GMO is settled. No harmful side effects have been noted in all these years, and millions of lives impacted positively. A couple of years ago, over 100 Nobel laureates signed a petition asserting that GM foods were safe, and blasting anti-science NGOs that stood in the way of progress. There is scientific consensus on this.
The science may be settled, but the politics is not. The government still bans some types of GM seeds, such as Bt brinjal, which was developed by an Indian company called Mahyco, and used successfully in Bangladesh. More crucially, a variety called HT Bt cotton, which fights weeds, is also banned. Weeding takes up to 15% of a farmer’s time, and often makes farming unviable. Farmers across the world use this variant — 60% of global cotton crops are HT Bt. Indian farmers are so desperate for it that they choose to break the law and buy expensive seeds from the black market — but the government is cracking down. A farmer in Haryana had his crop destroyed by the government in May.
On June 10 this year, a farmer named Lalit Bahale in the Akola district of Maharashtra kicked off a satyagraha by planting banned seeds of HT Bt cotton and Bt brinjal. He was soon joined by thousands of farmers. Far from our urban eyes, a heroic fight has begun. Our farmers, already victimised and oppressed by a predatory government in countless ways, are fighting for their right to take charge of their lives.
As this brave struggle unfolds, I am left with a troubling question: All those satyagrahas of the past by our great freedom fighters, what were they for, if all they got us was independence and not freedom?
End of Article
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA