Opinion

Editorial: Would Trump tell white congressmen: 'Go back where you came from'?

Thursday, July 18, 2019 -- Would President Donald Trump tell four white congressmen who disagreed with his policies to go back to where "they" came from? Spin, obfuscate, twist and deny all they want, those who should be holding the president accountable for his words and action - particularly the congressional Republicans from North Carolina - are derelict in their duty.

Posted Updated

CBC Editorial: Thursday, July 18, 2019; Editorial #8445
The following is the opinion of Capitol Broadcasting Company.

How does anyone demonstrate their love for America?

They can do it by participating in the United States’ democracy even in the face of dismissal from those who disagree, hatred from those who belittle and even violence from those who are prejudiced.

Four women have been showing love for their nation by doing what real Americans do. They are appropriately speaking out, participating in the electoral process, doing their jobs as members of Congress to hold the executive branch of their government accountable and pursuing policies they support.

But, for that they have been reviled in the most un-American way. And by our nation’s president, no less.
Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, Rashida Tlaib of Michigan and Ayanna Pressley of Massachusetts are loyal citizens. They offered themselves to public service and voters honored them to be their voices in the U.S. House of Representatives.

It doesn’t get more American than that.

Loving America is not measured in agreement with the president. Loving America doesn’t require a certain color of skin, place of birth, gender, religious faith or physical ability.

Loving America does not mean worshiping Donald Trump.

But President Trump has, contrary to our patriotic ways, demanded if they don’t like HIS policies they can “go back and help fix the totally broken and crime infested places from which they came.”

It was a racist reference to their ethnic heritage. All four are American citizens. It seems as though the president assumes all dark-skinned people were born in other countries and are not “real” Americans.

It was not about the actual places they live in the United States or represent in Congress. Three of these women were born in the United States. Ilhan Omar came to America when she was 14 from a Somalian refugee camp.

Would Trump tell four white congressmen who disagreed with his policies to go back to where “they” came from?

Spin, obfuscate, twist and deny all they want, those who should be holding the president accountable for his words and action – particularly the congressional Republicans from North Carolina – are derelict in their duty.

Ironically, it is those who are the object of the president’s horrible vilification and bigotry who are doing their jobs.

The U.S. House was right to pass a resolution “condemning President Trump’s racist comments directed at members of Congress.” North Carolina’s Republicans should have joined Democratic Reps. Alma Adams, GK Butterfield, and David Price to support it.
It’s hard to figure out what universe Sen. Thom Tillis might be in given his defense of Trump’s remarks. “The president’s not a racist, he’s not a xenophobe. He’s the son of an immigrant, he’s the husband of an immigrant. And people are trying to mischaracterize him,” said Tillis, who is seeking re-election and won Trump’s endorsement. Tillis seems to deny the obvious.
Democrat Price won’t have any of it. “Give me a break, this is extreme stuff. A few Republicans have begun to denounce it, but they ought to denounce it in a full-throated way. We all ought to.  This is just not acceptable.”

Real Americans who are concerned about their country speak up and speak out. They share their ideas, put them and themselves in the public arena.

Standing for those ideals is patriotic. Standing with President Trump’s bigotry is hollow and expedient.

The silence from North Carolina’s congressional Republicans speaks volumes.

Copyright 2024 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.