Allahabad HC to Sitapur admin: Do not go against principles of natural justice

On January 25, the court also asked the government to state “as to under what circumstances such an exorbitant amount of personal bond and two sureties have been asked”.

During the hearing on Tuesday, Additional Advocate General VK Shahi, representing the state government, told the court that notices had been issued to 162 people for executing a bond of Rs 10 lakh and two sureties of the like amount. Shahi said of the 162, 43 people appeared before authorities in the matter and on the basis of a fresh challani report, the proceedings against all of them were dropped “as there is no further apprehension to breach of peace or disturbance of public tranquillity”.

Shahi, however, could not “justify the act” of the Sub-Divisional Magistrates (SDMs) of various divisions working under the Sitapur District Magistrate (DM), who was a respondent in the case.

The government advocate assured Justices Ramesh Sinha and Rajeev Singh that he “shall instruct” the DM “to be careful in future while any such proceedings are initiated so that no unnecessary harassment is caused to any person and further to instruct the SDMs working under him”.

Following the lawyer’s statement, the judges said they hope and trust that the DM and the SDMs “shall be cautious in passing orders in any proceedings of such a nature calling upon the persons to execute personal bond and sureties and their orders, act and conduct should not be such which reflects arbitrariness and against the principles of natural justice”. The PIL was then disposed of by the court.