The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© KYODOJapan mulls delaying controversial Sado mine list for World Heritage
TOKYO©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© KYODO
21 Comments
Login to comment
dagon
UNESCO's World Heritage Committee last year adopted a resolution stating that Japan has failed to provide a sufficient explanation regarding the Korean victims of wartime forced labor at the Hashima Coal Mine off Nagasaki.
Gunkanjima has many amazing sights and should be memorialized. How about balancing it out by having the companies who benefited from forced labor, some prominent names in Japan Inc. and connected to LDP bigwigs like Aso and Abe, responsible for full disclosure and compensation?
Tom Doley
Japan attempting to whitewash everything in order to save face. What's wrong? Can't face reality like Germany? Or not adult enough to own up to your mistakes? Root cause of all this is Japan's tatamae culture.
MilesTeg
Went on vacation to Sado Isle about 10yrs ago. Lovely, very quiet place during summer with some nice beaches. We visited the mine (Kinzan) which is now a museum. As a museum, it's quite interesting. I researched a little before going and learned that Koreans, Chinese, even Japanese criminals and political dissidents were jailed at Kinzan and underwent forced labour. Mines are dangerous places to work so you can imagine how bad it was for those people.
There is no official record of how many prisoners died there. Some say 2,000 others 5,000 others even more. The reason being, those records seem to have miraculously disappeared. There wasn't even one display, a plaque, memorial to inform visitors of the thousands of prisoners who died there mining gold under horrendous conditions. It's like those people never existed. We all know what Japanese POW camps were like. Kinzan was no different.
It doesn't surprise me that Japan is trying to get KInzan, a place of death, torture, abuse, and despair, turned into a UNESCO World Heritage site. Talk about the irony. Talk about the usual Japanese whitewashing and refusal to accept their past.
Cricky
Yes it should be a world Heritage site, like a concentration camp in Europe, a site of misery, cruelty.
MilesTeg
It's not surprising to see right wing, ignorant and misinformed Japanese represented on this site giving minuses to any criticism of their past like Kinzan on Sado Isle. They're too scared to express their opinions to your face but on the internet they thrive under anonymity.
David Brent
Spot on. The chasm between the Germans and the Japanese is enormous. It will never change.
Kuruki
The Japanese government seems to view these locations associated to slave labor and torture as places to be marveled and celebrated.
mardarius
Japan showing its true colors again
Aly Rustom
exactly
Yes. Extremely troubling.
Deep respect to you Thomas
Jessie Lee
These UNESCO heritage sites are a marketing scam
Legrande
It doesn't surprise me that Japan is trying to get KInzan, a place of death, torture, abuse, and despair, turned into a UNESCO World Heritage site. Talk about the irony. Talk about the usual Japanese whitewashing and refusal to accept their past.
Yes it is not surprising, given that the people who founded the LDP were war criminals restored to power by the US.
In this regard it isn't so much that they are attempting to whitewash, more like they are trying to legitimate their past in the eyes of others.
Aly Rustom
Thanks bro!
Aly Rustom
Yup! Abe's Grandfather Kishi used CIA slush funds and Yakuza money to build the LDP
Well of course! The Kempeitai Japan's Gestapo and Tokkō Japan's **Thought Police** became the Mombusho or the Ministry of Education.
The upper eschalons of power in Japan are a horrific cesspool
Mr Kipling
Expat.....
Auschwitz is a UNESCO World Heritage site. But I don't think Japan wants its old gold mines to have this kind of heritage.
Mr Kipling
Tom Doley...
There's that and the fact that many in power now are the grand children and great grandchildren of those in powerful positions at the time of these crimes.
MilesTeg
Hey Thomas Goodtime! Apologies if I implied that all Japanese are like that. I know there are many who are capable of critical thinking and who acknowledge your country's past.
It's the same in every country. We all have our shame. As a Canadian, it sickens me that we stole everything they had and put Japanese Canadian citizens in internment camps during WWII. That our government and the catholic church were responsible for the sexual, physical, and mental abuse and murder of thousands of native children. We can deny or forget these incidents.
Tom San
Korean opposition again?
Some folks would have you believe that anything ever built between 1939 - 1945 was by Korean "slaves" and that not a single one of them willingly signed up to work or was paid for working in the mines, in the factories, in the fields, etc.
rolls eyes